%20(1).webp)

A solicitor writes to ask how you satisfied yourself that your patient’s account was accurate. The report is eighteen months old. The assessment took ninety minutes, the ASRS came back at six of six on Part A, the childhood account matched the criteria item for item, and there was no informant.
You diagnosed, and you were probably right. But the letter asks what you did about symptom validity, and the honest answer is nothing you can name. That is the real gap. The question is not whether your patients are lying to you, because the overwhelming majority are not. It is whether your process would show the accuracy of what you were told.
Over-endorsement on a self-report scale is a property of the measurement, not a judgement of character. Most elevated scores come from genuine distress, limited insight, a patient who has read about ADHD and now recognises everything, or someone who has waited years and is frightened of being dismissed.
Dong and colleagues studied 464 adults presenting consecutively for an adult ADHD evaluation at a university outpatient clinic in Germany. 28.2% failed two or more embedded validity indicators, and 59.1% failed at least one. The authors did not attribute this to malingering, and called for research that separates the different reasons for underperformance. The number does not mean a quarter of referrals are feigning. It means an assessor who treats a flag as a finding will often be wrong.
Validity is shown by a process, not measured by a score.
The evidential problem is not exaggeration. It is that brief screening tools were never built to bear the weight now put on them. Chamberlain, Cortese and Grant gave the ASRS v1.1 screener to 642 UK and 579 US adults from the general population. Positive screen rates were 26.0% in the UK sample and 17.3% in the US sample, against an expected prevalence of about 2.5%, giving an estimated positive predictive value of only around 11.5%.
That is a base-rate problem, not a dishonesty problem. A screen tuned for sensitivity will over-identify among people answering honestly. Our guide to what a positive ADHD screen actually means covers the ASRS, WURS and CAARS in more detail.
NICE guideline NG87 bases diagnosis on a full clinical and psychosocial assessment, including a developmental and psychiatric history, observer reports and an assessment of mental state. The UKAAN adult ADHD assessment quality assurance standard, a consensus standard published in 2024, sets out the process in more detail: a total assessment time of at least two hours in most cases, a semi-structured interview with open questioning and probing, and at least moderate impairment in two or more domains. It does not address symptom validity testing.
Several instruments are cited as detecting feigned ADHD. Three things are true of them, and knowing them saves a lot of misplaced confidence.
It is often assumed that patients who have read widely about ADHD will beat any validity measure. The evidence is less clear. In the Fuermaier study, giving simulators information about the diagnostic criteria or the test procedure did not help them feign ADHD more convincingly, although the authors note that study coaching is a limited stand-in for real-world exposure.
The bigger limitation is where the evidence comes from. Almost all of it is analogue simulation, where volunteers are asked to pretend, and much of the literature on non-credible reporting comes from US college students assessed for academic accommodations or stimulant prescriptions. Treating those figures as the expected rate in a UK adult clinic is not supportable.
Handle it as you would any weak evidence: weigh it against everything else, and say in the report what weight you gave it and why. Over-endorsement changes how much the self-report contributes. It is not a reason to end an assessment.
Each item below has a common innocent cause, and most resolve without concern. None supports a conclusion on its own, and one that resolves should be written up as resolved rather than left hanging as an implication.
One item is deliberately absent. An informant whose account differs from the patient’s is not a warning sign. Agreement between self-report and informant report in adult ADHD is only low to moderate, as Mörstedt and colleagues found, and the difference is data about observability, not honesty. Our article on informant and self-report discrepancy covers how to weigh the two. Where the only informant was briefed in detail or has a stake in the outcome, name that limitation rather than discounting the account. For structuring the conversation itself, see our guide to the informant interview and collateral history.
The hardest part is the writing, and three situations recur.
Where the self-report is elevated but corroboration is thin, say that you did not weight the total score, and name exactly what could not be corroborated.
Where self-report and informant account diverge, say that a discrepancy of this kind is common and does not by itself indicate inaccuracy in either, and treat the two accounts as complementary rather than competing.
The third is the one most often avoided. Where you cannot reach a conclusion, say so. Say it reflects the limits of the information, not a judgement about the patient, name what is outstanding, and state plainly that the person has not been assessed and found not to have ADHD. Our guide to writing the ADHD diagnostic report covers report structure more broadly.
It is possible to exaggerate symptoms on a questionnaire, but a careful assessment does not rest on a questionnaire. Corroboration from records and informants, and a probed interview with real examples, make an accurate picture far more likely. Most elevated scores reflect distress or over-recognition, not deliberate feigning.
Not one established for routine UK adult practice. The available indicators flag response patterns. They do not establish intent.
No. Fatigue, anxiety about the outcome, careless responding and genuine impairment can all produce failures, and they are far more common explanations.
There is no ADHD-specific validity test established for routine UK practice, so validity is something your process demonstrates rather than something a score measures. The defence against the solicitor’s letter is documented triangulation, not an instrument.
Global ADHD Network’s ADHD assessor training covers interview method, corroboration and report writing in depth.
